Harry Potter - The Hogwarts Experience

Come share the Magic and remember: Never tickle a Purple Hippo!
 
HomePublicationsSearchRegisterHogwarts QuillLog in
Announcement Board
Check the news/announcements/updated thread HERE
Please be patient while HE is undergoing some major changes, we're trying to improve it for a new era.

YEAR 12



Log in
Username:
Password:
Log in automatically: 
:: I forgot my password
Housepoints

Hufflepuff: 20,650 HP
Ravenclaw: 2,966 HP
Slytherin: 1,788 HP
Gryffindor: 1,511 HP







ShoutBox
HE Staff
Admin


Deputy Head


Heads of House



Second Heads of House
Gryffindor: TBA
Ravenclaw: TBA
Hufflepuff: TBA
Slytherin: TBA

Other Positions
Head Students
(February 2017 - February 2018)
NatalieSS

TBA
Prefects
(February 2015 - February2016)
TBA
Classes
Ancient Runes
Professor: TBA


Arithmancy
Professor: amberg93

Charms
Professor: Sashi

Flying Lessons
Professor: TBA

Healer Studies
Professor: TBA

Herbology
Professor: TBA

Mythology

Professor: amortentia773

Potions
Professor: TBA

Transfiguration
Professor: TBA
HE Daily Trivia


Don't forget do play the Daily Trivia. There will be a bunch of points available for the Top 10 Players at the end of each month!

Hurry up, then, click HERE!
Latest topics
» Norse God of the Week (7)
Narcissa Malfoy Debate 1 Emptyby Raistlin The Wizard Tue Oct 01 2019, 12:57

» Norse God of the Week (6)
Narcissa Malfoy Debate 1 Emptyby Raistlin The Wizard Tue Oct 01 2019, 12:22

» Creature Chronicles: NatalieSS
Narcissa Malfoy Debate 1 Emptyby NatalieSS Tue Sep 24 2019, 09:52

» Norse God of the Week (5)
Narcissa Malfoy Debate 1 Emptyby Raistlin The Wizard Sun Sep 22 2019, 12:09

» Sorting Request Post
Narcissa Malfoy Debate 1 Emptyby Raistlin The Wizard Sun Sep 22 2019, 11:50

» Sorting List (look here to see where you have been sorted)
Narcissa Malfoy Debate 1 Emptyby Raistlin The Wizard Sun Sep 22 2019, 11:49

» Norse God of the Week (4)
Narcissa Malfoy Debate 1 Emptyby Raistlin The Wizard Sun Sep 22 2019, 11:47

» Norse God of the Week (3)
Narcissa Malfoy Debate 1 Emptyby Raistlin The Wizard Sun Sep 22 2019, 11:43

» Norse God of the Week (2)
Narcissa Malfoy Debate 1 Emptyby Raistlin The Wizard Sun Sep 22 2019, 11:41

» Heroes and the Twelve Olympians
Narcissa Malfoy Debate 1 Emptyby Raistlin The Wizard Sun Sep 22 2019, 11:37

» Being of the Moment 3: Greek Mythology
Narcissa Malfoy Debate 1 Emptyby Raistlin The Wizard Sat Sep 21 2019, 05:27

» Lair of the Sphinx (5)
Narcissa Malfoy Debate 1 Emptyby Raistlin The Wizard Sat Sep 21 2019, 03:43

» Lair of the Sphinx (3)
Narcissa Malfoy Debate 1 Emptyby Raistlin The Wizard Sat Sep 21 2019, 03:33

» Lair of the Sphinx (4)
Narcissa Malfoy Debate 1 Emptyby Raistlin The Wizard Sat Sep 21 2019, 03:27

» [TOURNAMENTS]: Year 12 - Instructions & Sign-ups & Round Requests
Narcissa Malfoy Debate 1 Emptyby NatalieSS Wed Sep 18 2019, 14:03

» [DEBATES TOURNAMENT]: Year 12 - Round 1 - Tea or Coffee?
Narcissa Malfoy Debate 1 Emptyby NatalieSS Wed Sep 18 2019, 14:00

» Egyptian God of the Week (1)
Narcissa Malfoy Debate 1 Emptyby Raistlin The Wizard Sun Sep 15 2019, 12:56

» Norse God of the Week (1)
Narcissa Malfoy Debate 1 Emptyby Raistlin The Wizard Sun Sep 15 2019, 12:46

» Greek Mythology Crossword
Narcissa Malfoy Debate 1 Emptyby Raistlin The Wizard Sun Sep 15 2019, 12:30

» Mythology Quotes II: Fallen Puzzle
Narcissa Malfoy Debate 1 Emptyby Raistlin The Wizard Sun Sep 15 2019, 12:26

» Mythology Quotes I: Fallen Puzzle
Narcissa Malfoy Debate 1 Emptyby Raistlin The Wizard Sun Sep 15 2019, 10:16

» What Mythological Creature Are You?
Narcissa Malfoy Debate 1 Emptyby Raistlin The Wizard Sun Sep 15 2019, 10:04

» General House Common Room Part 24
Narcissa Malfoy Debate 1 Emptyby Raistlin The Wizard Sat Aug 10 2019, 10:18

» CoMC Double Puzzle I
Narcissa Malfoy Debate 1 Emptyby avablacky Sat Dec 16 2017, 14:05

» Students Workload - Report Here
Narcissa Malfoy Debate 1 Emptyby avablacky Tue Dec 12 2017, 23:09

» Toy Maker Badge
Narcissa Malfoy Debate 1 Emptyby avablacky Tue Dec 12 2017, 23:02

» What Are You Wearing Right Now?
Narcissa Malfoy Debate 1 Emptyby LoveLucifer Tue Dec 12 2017, 18:06

» Graphics-a-holic Record - Year 12
Narcissa Malfoy Debate 1 Emptyby Sashi Fri Sep 29 2017, 17:44

» [ICONS TOURNAMENT]: Year 12 - Round 1 - Life Through a Window
Narcissa Malfoy Debate 1 Emptyby Sashi Fri Sep 29 2017, 17:34

» Readings from beyond #1
Narcissa Malfoy Debate 1 Emptyby AlabastorCrowley Tue Sep 19 2017, 17:32

» WAND EXAMINATIONS (1st Years and above sign up here)
Narcissa Malfoy Debate 1 Emptyby RedundantBadger Tue Sep 19 2017, 16:57

» Constellations
Narcissa Malfoy Debate 1 Emptyby RedundantBadger Tue Sep 19 2017, 13:35

» Colors of Stars
Narcissa Malfoy Debate 1 Emptyby RedundantBadger Tue Sep 19 2017, 13:10

» Norse God of the Week (8)
Narcissa Malfoy Debate 1 Emptyby RedundantBadger Tue Sep 19 2017, 08:04

» Vault 25 - PetraHvězda
Narcissa Malfoy Debate 1 Emptyby Raistlin The Wizard Sun Sep 17 2017, 13:22

» Vault 24 - Adora Shadow
Narcissa Malfoy Debate 1 Emptyby Raistlin The Wizard Sun Sep 17 2017, 13:20

» Vault 23 - ctemple
Narcissa Malfoy Debate 1 Emptyby Raistlin The Wizard Sun Sep 17 2017, 13:18

» Vault 22 - Nixie_B_Dover
Narcissa Malfoy Debate 1 Emptyby Raistlin The Wizard Sun Sep 17 2017, 13:16

» Vault 21 - STRAWBERRY MANGO
Narcissa Malfoy Debate 1 Emptyby Raistlin The Wizard Sun Sep 17 2017, 13:11

» Vault 20 - NatalieSS
Narcissa Malfoy Debate 1 Emptyby Raistlin The Wizard Sun Sep 17 2017, 13:07

Term Cup Winners
Year 1 (1st Semester)
House Cup: Gryffindor
Quidditch Cup: Slytherin
Year 1 (2nd Semester)
House Cup: Slytherin
Quidditch Cup: Ravenclaw
Year 2 (1st Semester)
House Cup: Gryffindor
Quidditch Cup: Ravenclaw
Year 2 (2nd Semester)
House Cup: Hufflepuff
Quidditch Cup: Gryffindor
Year 3 (1st Semester)
House Cup: Ravenclaw
Quidditch Cup: Slytherin
Year 3 (2nd Semester)
House Cup: Ravenclaw
Quidditch Cup: Ravenclaw
Year 4 (Full Year)
House
Cup: Gryffindor
Quidditch Cup: Hiatus
Year 5 (Full Year)
House Cup: Gryffindor
Quidditch Cup: Hiatus
Year 6 (Full Year)
House Cup: Gryffindor
Quidditch Cup: Hiatus
Year 7 (Full Year)
House Cup: Slytherin
Quidditch Cup: Hiatus
Year 8 (Full Year)
House Cup: Slytherin
Quidditch Cup: Hiatus
Year 9 (Full Year)
House Cup: Gryffindor
Quidditch Cup: Hiatus
Year 10 (Full Year)
House Cup: Gryffindor
Quidditch Cup: Hiatus
Year 11 (Full Year)
House Cup: Hufflepuff
Quidditch Cup: Hufflepuff
Recent Exam Passes
amortentia773
Astronomy OWL - Class E: History of the Planets
amortentia773
Astronomy OWL - Class B: Astronomy Today
amortentia773
Astronomy OWL - Class A: Observation Astronomy
amortentia773
Astronomy OWL - Class C: Galaxy quest
amortentia773
Level 5 : Animagus Transformation
amortentia773
Level 6 : Final Exam : Knowledge of Animagus
amortentia773
Level 7 : Register Your Animagus
Featured Member

Affiliates/Topsites
lease vote daily in the following sites to keep our site on top and hopefully attract more members:


These are our static affiliates:

Gordon Parks' Academy
wands at the ready
HOS
Potter's Army
FIGHT LIKE GODSNarcissa Malfoy Debate 1 Mhbutton
GRAPHICS GAMES

Affiliate With Us
If you would like to affiliate with the Hogwarts Experience simply take the link image code below to put onto your site. To have your affiliate here, please PM Raistlin The Wizard or post your button HERE. Please remember, Hogwarts Experience will only affiliate with sites that have our own affiliate link on them.
Add us as an affiliate:


Share
 

 Narcissa Malfoy Debate 1

Go down 
AuthorMessage
violetriddle
5th Year
5th Year
violetriddle

Female
Country : Narcissa Malfoy Debate 1 Flag_u10
Regist. date : 2008-02-14
Number of posts : 35370
Age : 26
Location : Alabama
Real First Name : Lesley
Warning :
Narcissa Malfoy Debate 1 Left_bar_bleue0 / 30 / 3Narcissa Malfoy Debate 1 Right_bar_bleue

House : The Wonderful House of Salazar Slytherin
Crest : Narcissa Malfoy Debate 1 Slythe10
Wand : Walnut & Dragon Heartstring
Award Bar :
Narcissa Malfoy Debate 1 Left_bar_bleue203 / 700203 / 700Narcissa Malfoy Debate 1 Right_bar_bleue


Narcissa Malfoy Debate 1 Empty
PostSubject: Narcissa Malfoy Debate 1   Narcissa Malfoy Debate 1 EmptyFri Sep 23 2011, 16:16


Narcissa Malfoy- a loving mother or scared follower?

In the last Harry Potter book, the Deathly Hallows, we learned that Narcissa Malfoy was willing to do anything to protect her son- even if it meant disobeying the Dark Lord. Now, let’s take in the idea that Draco was, in fact, with them the whole time in the forest. Do you think Narcissa’s answer would have changed to ‘no, he is a live,’ or remained the same? In this debate, each team needs to give me their idea on why it would have changed and why it would stay the same. Sources count, so provide them if you have any.

Pro Team: it would remain the same answer
Con Team: it would have changed

Each debate is open for a month. If the Con team goes first, then it should follow a con, pro, con, pro sequence and likewise if the Pro team goes first. Try to not go out of order so it makes grading easier. Also, try not to put much into one post so you have much to use later.


This will be open for one month
Back to top Go down
amortentia773
Hufflepuff Head of House : CoMC & Mythology Professor : 5th Year
Hufflepuff Head of House : CoMC & Mythology Professor : 5th Year
amortentia773

Female
Country : Narcissa Malfoy Debate 1 Flag_a10
Regist. date : 2010-07-29
Number of posts : 17484
Age : 24
Location : Floating around the clouds
Real First Name : Katie
Warning :
Narcissa Malfoy Debate 1 Left_bar_bleue0 / 30 / 3Narcissa Malfoy Debate 1 Right_bar_bleue

House : Hufflepuff
Crest : Narcissa Malfoy Debate 1 Huffle10
Wand : Cherry & Phoenix Tail Feather
Award Bar :
Narcissa Malfoy Debate 1 Left_bar_bleue260 / 700260 / 700Narcissa Malfoy Debate 1 Right_bar_bleue


Narcissa Malfoy Debate 1 Empty
PostSubject: Re: Narcissa Malfoy Debate 1   Narcissa Malfoy Debate 1 EmptyThu Sep 29 2011, 12:15

Had Draco been at his mother's side throught the Battle of Hogwarts, there is no way Narcissa Malfoy's answer to Voldemort would not have changed from "Yes, Harry's dead" to "No, he's still alive". As she has showed countless times throughout the series, she, and her husband, are very fickle, switching sides when it bests suits their needs, but in the case of Narcissa, she is also very protective of her only son. There are many examples of this throughout the book, but I will start out with the background for her protectiveness of her son.

First off, Narcissa and her husband claimed to be under the Imperius Curse throughout the First Wizarding War, avoiding Azkaban prison, showing their self-interest, choosing the side that they truly believe will win. So when Narcissa detects that Harry is still, in fact, alive, that was a moment where she obviously had to consider, beyond just her son which was her major reasons for answering the way she did, that Harry, who was able to withstand the Killing Curse twice now, would most likely end up on the winning side, which convinced her that lying to Voldemort might be enough to get her out of Azkaban a second time, which we know, was in fact the case as she and her family were pardoned for their crimes through her lie to Voldemort.

However, her fickle behavior was not the major reason for her answers, but her protectiveness over her son, as stated before. In 1991, when Draco was first heading off to attend school, we later learn that Lucius wanted him to attend Durmstrang Institute, known for the Dark Arts and admittance for only pure-bloods and half-bloods. However, Narcissa was unable to put such distance between herself and her son and insisted that Draco go to school locally, at Hogwarts. If she couldn't even imagine him being out of the country at school, there's no way she would have been okay with a war lasting longer than it already had when she was not aware if her son was alive or dead. We also know that Narcissa was so devoted to her son that she sent him sweets by owl every day at school; taking the time to give that much attention and love to her son should be enough to make clear that her answer would have changed; she would not put him at such needless risk.

It is also known that following her proclamation, both her and her husband ignored the rest of the Battle of Hogwarts, only focused on finding Draco. If her son was not the reason for her answer, why would she enter the battle just to find Draco? No, it is clear that had Draco been in the forest, there would have been no reason for Narcissa to lie to Voldemort; without her son, her fear for Draco's life rose above her desire to be on whichever side was to win.

With the son she adores so with him, there would be nothing for her in lying to Voldemort that Harry was dead. By saying that Harry was dead, it enabled her to search for her son much more quickly than if Voldemort had learned that Harry was, in fact alive. Why would she put herself, her husband and her precious son at risk by lying to Voldemort if her whole family was together and safe? She would have handed Harry over quickly not only to stop the war, but to put her family back into the safety of Voldemort's favor.


Sources: http://harrypotter.wikia.com/wiki/Narcissa_Malfoy
Harry Potter and the Sorceror's Stone
Harry Potter and the Half-Blood Prince
Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows

_________________
Narcissa Malfoy Debate 1 Sig10
Narcissa Malfoy Debate 1 Amorte11
H U F F L E P U F F  P R I D E
Back to top Go down
http://lostamongfantasy.tumblr.com/
amberg93
Deputy Head : Gryffindor HoH : Arithmancy & Arts & Muggle Studies Professor : 5th Year
Deputy Head : Gryffindor HoH : Arithmancy & Arts & Muggle Studies Professor : 5th Year
amberg93

Female
Country : Narcissa Malfoy Debate 1 Flag_c10
Regist. date : 2006-03-11
Number of posts : 16910
Age : 26
Location : Canada :P
Real First Name : Amber/Amby :D
Warning :
Narcissa Malfoy Debate 1 Left_bar_bleue0 / 30 / 3Narcissa Malfoy Debate 1 Right_bar_bleue

House : Gryffindor!
Crest : Narcissa Malfoy Debate 1 Gryffi10
Wand : Exam not taken
Award Bar :
Narcissa Malfoy Debate 1 Left_bar_bleue391 / 700391 / 700Narcissa Malfoy Debate 1 Right_bar_bleue


Narcissa Malfoy Debate 1 Empty
PostSubject: Re: Narcissa Malfoy Debate 1   Narcissa Malfoy Debate 1 EmptySun Oct 02 2011, 09:48

Naricssa Malfoy is a smart woman and certainly one of self interest and therefore her answer in the forest would have remained the same whether or not Draco was standing by her side. Now, some may say that she, as a woman of self interest, would change her answer so to better protect her family and herself. However, I present to you the case that it was in her best interest all along to lie to Voldemort about Harry being dead because she had the most to gain from Voldemort falling.

Imagine a world where Lord Voldemort reigns without Harry Potter to trump him. It'd be so much different than the world in the seventh Harry Potter book. Oh wait, it wouldn't be. See, even if Harry Potter wasn't around there would still be a war going on. As Neville stands up to say when Harry is brought back supposedly dead, there would be many that continued to fight against Voldemort. This would mean that Narcissa's family would continuously be in danger still. Her son would be put in the middle of fighting, her husband as well, even herself. There would always be a large resistance toward Voldemort and the war would continue on for a long while still. What would she have to gain from that? Especially, with the strong chance at the end of it that she wouldn't come out on the right side. Voldemort had fallen before and even with Harry dead, his best friends would be alive to continue his work and try to get him out of the way.

There was also more to risk in that very moment by saying that Harry was alive. What if a fight broke out right in the forest? With Draco in the middle of it? The risk that her son could get hit wouldn't be one that Narcissa would be willing to take. Nor would she be willing to take the risk that she would get hit for the sake of Voldemort. By lying she was able to give herself a bit of leeway to get out of there when Voldemort did discover that he was alive because obviously it'd create quite a scene and probably a panic. Also, she was giving the other side a chance to win. She realizes that Harry Potter is a good, loyal sort of fellow and that if he survives and wins, he won't let anything happen to her family or herself because she saved his life. He'd remember that debt and give her family a way to walk away from the happenings without punishment. Harry had the better chance of ending the war swiftly, of stopping the danger for her family, and of just giving her something more to look forward to.

By telling the truth to Voldemort, she wouldn't gain favor with him. Not in the low statue that her family was already in with Voldemort. There was no standing left for them to gain on that side, so Narcissa, being the smart woman that she is, would have kept her answer because it's the one with which she had the most to gain.


Sources
http://www.hp-lexicon.org/wizards/narcissa.html
Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows

_________________
Narcissa Malfoy Debate 1 Holland_zpstyujhpqz
Narcissa Malfoy Debate 1 Mmx8z2bmmmrp4jlc
Narcissa Malfoy Debate 1 Gryffi11
Back to top Go down
http://www.heartofamerica.proboards49.com
Sponsored content




Narcissa Malfoy Debate 1 Empty
PostSubject: Re: Narcissa Malfoy Debate 1   Narcissa Malfoy Debate 1 Empty

Back to top Go down
 
Narcissa Malfoy Debate 1
Back to top 
Page 1 of 1

Permissions in this forum:You cannot reply to topics in this forum
Harry Potter - The Hogwarts Experience :: The Hogwarts Experience Castle :: Fourth Floor :: Debate and Discussion Classroom-
Jump to: